A result, measured the night it happened
The same file. Three questions. Three answers.
A master is not good or bad in the abstract. It
is good for somewhere. On 27 and 28 September 2026 one master of
Cosmic Honey — the “radio ready” version
of 31 August, made with an AI mastering tool — went through AudioVibes
three times.
Its measurements did not change across the three runs: −8.37 LUFS integrated,
−0.86 dBTP true peak, 2.73 LU loudness range. Only the
question asked of it did.
| Genre profile | Delivery target | Score | What decided it |
| General | Spotify | 81.0 |
5.6 LU louder than Spotify’s −14, so the platform turns it down; true peak over the −1 dBTP ceiling. |
| Rock | Spotify | 78.8 |
The same, and rock asks for more movement: 5–11 LU against the file’s 2.73. |
| Rock | Club / DJ | 92.7 |
Loudness and true peak both inside the club window. Release ready. |
Crops of the three saved reports, left to right in the order of the table. Select one to open it full size.
The loudness was right for
the club and wrong for streaming. The flat dynamics were wrong for
both.
The narrow loudness range is flagged in all three runs, because that finding
belongs to the music, not the room. The original master of 6 August, before
the radio-ready pass, scored 94.9 against Spotify.
And the tool does not say stop. It shows when another pass has stopped
buying anything, or started costing. Deciding that too much is too much is
the producer’s call, and it is signed like the rest.
Stated at its true
scope. What moved is arithmetic against stated targets. How far it
moved is partly ours: the weight given to delivery in the total is a
declared choice, and the genre profiles are declared starting points that
have not yet been checked against a corpus of masters. Spotify publishes
its −14 LUFS; the club figure of −8 is industry convention, not
a published standard. Measured in the only Certified ABA Production Studio
there is, by the only engineer certified in the ABA Conductor mix —
one of each, stated as a count so nobody reads it as more.
Use the Middle C Keyboard with the toolbox: play any of the 88 keys and read its frequency and overtones, or export a note as a WAV test file whose frequency and level you already know.